Sandwiches in West End, Boston

Explore the sandwiches menu at Overtime Pizza with pickup available, serving West End, Boston, MA with bold, satisfying options nightly.

Order online

Popular Sandwiches to Try

GRILLED CHEESE ANIMAL STYLE

$10.95

Grilled cheese with tenders, mozzarella sticks, fries, and Buffalo sauce.

“Love this place, it is one of my favorites for a late night snack! Favorite item is the animal style grilled cheese. Who knew you could put all those things in there, highly recommend!”

STEAK MELT

$10.45

Grilled cheese with shaved steak, grilled onions, and chipotle mayo.

CHICKEN PARM SUB

$12.95

A chicken cutlet sub with American cheese and marinara sauce.

At the Heart of Overtime Pizza

Overtime Pizza brings a bold sandwiches lineup to West End, Boston, MA, with chicken sandwiches and grilled cheeses crafted to satisfy late-night and everyday cravings alike.

Dig into the CLASSIC CHICKEN SANDWICH, OT SIGNATURE CHICKEN SANDWICH, BUFFALO CHICKEN SANDWICH, HOT HONEY CHICKEN SANDWICH, PATTY MELT, or the loaded GRILLED CHEESE ANIMAL STYLE — each built to order.

Visit Overtime Pizza in West End, Boston, MA or get your sandwiches fix your way — pickup, dine-in, delivery, and catering options make it easy to enjoy any night of the week.

Sandwiches to Try

BUFFALO CHICKEN SANDWICH

$10.45

A chicken sandwich dressed with buffalo sauce, lettuce, and ranch.

CLASSIC CHICKEN SANDWICH

$10.45

A chicken sandwich topped with lettuce, mayonnaise, and pickles.

CLASSIC GRILLED CHEESE

$7.95

Toasted bread surrounds melted cheese in this classic sandwich.

HOT HONEY CHICKEN SANDWICH

$10.95

A chicken sandwich with hot honey, lettuce, mayonnaise, and pickles.

PATTY MELT

$9.45

A grilled cheese sandwich with burger patty, bacon, and OT sauce.

OT SIGNATURE CHICKEN SANDWICH

$10.95

A chicken sandwich with OT sauce, lettuce, and pickles.

Frequently Asked Questions

What are your most popular sandwiches options?

Our guests love these customer favorites. If you're visiting us these are some of the food options we recommend most often.

STEAK MELT — This sandwich combines shaved steak and grilled onions with grilled cheese and chipotle mayonnaise inside.
GRILLED CHEESE ANIMAL STYLE — This toasted sandwich contains melted cheese, chicken tenders, mozzarella sticks, fries, and Buffalo sauce inside.
CHICKEN PARM SUB — This sub layers a chicken cutlet, American cheese, and marinara sauce inside a sub roll.
BUFFALO CHICKEN SANDWICH — This sandwich features chicken, buffalo sauce, lettuce, and ranch in one layered combination on the sandwich.
PATTY MELT — This sandwich combines a burger patty and bacon with grilled cheese and OT sauce between toasted bread.

Do you offer delivery and takeout?

Yes! We offer both delivery and takeout for sandwiches throughout the West End, Boston area. Order your sandwiches online for convenient pickup or delivery.